Chinese officials’ crackdown on crypto mining and trading, which first began in May 2021, has already negatively impacted the local crypto industry. (Photo courtesy of Bermix Studios)

What’s in store for the decentralised crypto industry with China’s growing antagonism?

China's stance may be concerning today, but won't affect the global industry in the long run.

Chinese authorities seemed intent on razing the country’s cryptocurrency mining activities, recently adding the mining of bitcoin and other digital tokens to a proposed blacklist of industrial activities that they insist must be abandoned. This is supposedly part of the country’s 2026 carbon neutrality push.

This stance deals a massive blow to the global crypto mining industry, where the Red Dragon is a leading market. At times, China-based mining operations reportedly controlled as much as 65% of Bitcoin’s global hash rate, according to data from the University of Cambridge’s Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index. 

Even before the blacklist suggestion, Chinese officials’ crackdown on crypto mining and trading, which first began in May 2021, has already negatively impacted the local crypto industry. 

“Crypto trading decreased alongside these crackdowns and the mining ban,” said Ulisse Dell’Orto, APAC Managing Director of blockchain platform Chainalysis. “Specifically, major exchanges halted derivatives trading. We hypothesise that much of this activity has migrated to [decentralised finance], but that hasn’t picked up enough that it makes up for the losses in the derivatives market yet.”

It is also negatively impacting the global cryptocurrency industry. China is one of the industry’s biggest players, with addresses estimated to be controlled by users in the country, having received over $150m worth of cryptocurrency as of January 2021, second to the United States, according to a report by Chainalysis. 

Its effect on the global space, however, is not expected to broach beyond the near term, said Don Guo, co-founder and CEO of Singapore’s Broctagon Fintech Group, a multi-asset liquidity and technology solutions provider. “[For] now the crackdown might seem concerning. But the reality is that it won’t affect the global cryptocurrency pricing and industry in the long run. The utility and ownership of bitcoin have become broader over time,” he said.

Noting that the country banned ICOs or initial coin offerings in the past, Guo is not surprised by China’s antagonistic stance against cryptocurrency. For years, China has signaled that it wanted to ban bitcoin.

But whilst the global crypto market may be assured that things would soon go back to normal, in China, the crypto mining and trading industry has no escape—with the ban expected to push 90% of mining in the country to go offline, Guo said.

Do not expect crypto trading and mining businesses to just fade quietly; they might just set up shop elsewhere, turning their sights from the Red Dragon to the Merlion. 

“In Singapore, a conducive framework for the industry has definitely attracted many renowned international blockchain and crypto firms,” noted Yushio Liu, CEO of Coinhako, a Singapore-based cryptocurrency platform. 

Apart from Singapore, many countries have yet to take a regulatory stance on the crypto industry, and these will be of interest to impacted businesses, Liu said. 

Liu also argued that the ban in China may not be the final nail in the coffin for cryptocurrencies in the country. There is a chance that China could pivot towards ESG-friendly cryptocurrency mining instead.

The CBDC dilemma
Around the same time that China began cracking down on global decentralised cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, the country began the initial phases of rolling out its central bank digital currency (CBDC). CBDCs differ from cryptocurrencies, like Bitcoin, because they are designed to operate outside of the control of any one government or organisation, according to Chainalysis’ Dell’Orto.

So are they a rainbow or a dark cloud hanging on the crypto industry’s horizon? Neither, according to industry experts.

“In general, we do not see CBDCs challenging existing cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and stablecoins. They can exist side by side and are not necessarily competitive,” Dell’Orto said.

Broctagon’s Guo agreed, saying: “CBDC and cryptocurrencies have different use cases and purposes. CBDCs are fiat currencies in digital form whilst cryptocurrencies are not legal tender in most countries.” The key features of cryptocurrencies are decentralisation and autonomy, the features that CBDCs lack, he added.

Both also have their own set of advantages: CBDCs in their tie to local currencies, and Bitcoin and other decentralised cryptocurrencies in that they are not controlled by one single entity, according to Coinhako’s Liu.

CBDCs can then be used to transact using digital versions of their country’s fiat currency, with no need to do conversions or the possibility of misunderstanding the value of their wallet. On the other hand, as decentralised cryptocurrencies are not controlled by a government or one organisation, many people can treat it as a store of value and hedge against inflation, Coinhako’s Liu said.

In fact, the roll-out of CBDCs may even bring a positive impact to the cryptocurrency industry.

“One thing that is certain—CBDCs, being digital legal tender, will speed up the awareness of digital payments. This, in turn, can raise awareness of cryptocurrencies, since the general public will likely equivocate between the two,” Guo said, noting that cryptocurrency trading is currently still small as compared to other commodities and trade-able products. “Introduction of CBDCs will push digital currency adoption into mainstream making it easier for citizens to transact.”

As for the future of CBDC roll-out, Coinhako’s Liu said that governments may opt to issue CBDCs directly to citizens with the assistance of AI over middlemen organisations like banks.

Join Asian Banking & Finance community
Since you're here...

...there are many ways you can work with us to advertise your company and connect to your customers. Our team can help you dight and create an advertising campaign, in print and digital, on this website and in print magazine.

We can also organize a real life or digital event for you and find thought leader speakers as well as industry leaders, who could be your potential partners, to join the event. We also run some awards programmes which give you an opportunity to be recognized for your achievements during the year and you can join this as a participant or a sponsor.

Let us help you drive your business forward with a good partnership!

Banks should have enough buffers and find climate transition risks manageable.
The products are now available at Eccellente by HAO Market in Singapore.
Institutional clients may accelerate time-to-market financial applications.
This was thanks to a rise in loans made to the service sector during the period.
Discussions between the two banks are at the preliminary stage.
But it reported weaker quarterly performance, largely due to its $309.8m Q3 expense.
Uncertainty over Omicron's impact may drive this slowdown.
Only 2 in 10 Singapore micro-multinationals think banks offer value for money.
The Internet boom has pushed 9 out of 10 digital merchants to accept digital payments.
It’s not as urgent as other markets with credit under-penetration, says TMRW Digital Group CCO.
The move is part of the BSP’s Digital Payments Transformation Roadmap.
Internet economy in SEA has propelled digital payments further.
The market is expected to top $83.2b in four years’ time.
The 3.26% interest rate average is its highest since November 2018.